Why I Do Not Recommend Baking Potatoes In Aluminum Foil (2024)

Wrapping potatoes to bake in aluminum foil should be outlawed! First of all, the original reason restaurants did this was to dress up the lowly potato and to hide any defects or bruises. So gold and aluminum foil sheets were painstakingly used to punish dishwashers and cooks who had some extra time on their hands… just my theory.

Why I Do Not Recommend Baking Potatoes In Aluminum Foil (1)

First reason… the potato is around 80% water. Trapping that spud in aluminum foil where the moisture cannot escape results in a wet potato. Over baking the potato in foil cannot be seen (or easy to smell that it is overcooked) so you can end up with dark brown skin on the bottom, tough to eat and giving off a slightly burnt taste.Just look at the skin on this beautiful baked potato, blogger Priscilla Willis did, with a vegetarian topping.

Why I Do Not Recommend Baking Potatoes In Aluminum Foil (2)

Second reason: Just as you suspected, foil wrapping adds to the cost of the potato with labor time. A study we did years ago showed wrapping a box of 90 counts to 15-30 minutes. Even at minimum wage, currently at $7.25 that is a $1.81 to $3.62 increase in the cost of putting those potatoes into the oven.

Third reason: The cost of those pretty little aluminum foil wraps are expensive too. On the web site right now at www.amazon.com 50 Reynolds pop up foil sheets cost $7.46 or 15 cents each! At centralrestaurant.com a box of 500 individual Reynolds aluminum foil individual sheets are $29.49 or 6 cents a potato.

If your restaurant is paying $15.00 for a carton of 90 count Idaho® potatoes they cost 16.7 cents apiece. In the examples above you nearly double the cost of the potato for the 50 sheets, and for the 500 sheets add nearly 36% to the cost.Why I Do Not Recommend Baking Potatoes In Aluminum Foil (3)

NEVER BAKE POTATOES IN FOIL.Foil wraps will not decrease baking time, but will result in a soggy potato interior with wet skin. Wrapping a baked potato in foil after it has been baked will allow you to hold up to 45 minutes, but the best method for holding a baked potato is in a bread warming drawer. Second best is to use a heat-proof cabinet.

Use a fork to pierce the skin in the form of a cross before serving. Do not cut with a knife as this flattens the surface and prevents the potato from being fluffy. Open the potato just before serving by pressing the ends toward the center and lifting and fluffing the meat of the potato with a fork.

Why I Do Not Recommend Baking Potatoes In Aluminum Foil (2024)

FAQs

Why I Do Not Recommend Baking Potatoes In Aluminum Foil? ›

Trapping that spud in aluminum foil where the moisture cannot escape results in a wet potato. Over baking the potato in foil cannot be seen (or easy to smell that it is overcooked) so you can end up with dark brown skin on the bottom, tough to eat and giving off a slightly burnt taste.

Why should you not bake potatoes in foil? ›

Wrapping a potato in foil prior to baking traps the potato's natural moisture, steaming instead of baking it. This results is a soggy baked potato, not the light fluffy Idaho Baker that most people prefer.

Why not use aluminum foil in oven? ›

Why can't I use aluminum foil as an oven liner? Using aluminum foil to keep your oven clean may be tempting, but lining an oven with foil increases the intensity of heat on oven surfaces that can lead to surface damage like scratching or chipping on the porcelain finish and damage to heating elements.

How does aluminum foil affect baking? ›

It's always a great idea to cover your dishes with aluminum foil while cooking at high temperatures in the oven. It protects your food from drying out or burning and helps keep in the heat and moisture, ensuring a perfectly cooked meal. Loosely covering your dish with foil can prevent uneven browning while baking.

Do potatoes react with aluminum? ›

According to the Idaho Potato Commission, aluminum or metal pans can react with cut potatoes, causing them to brown too quickly. While this isn't always the case, glass baking dishes and mixing bowls are a safer choice.

Why do restaurants bake potatoes in foil? ›

Some say wrapping baked potatoes in aluminum foil helps them cook faster (aluminum conducts heat, then traps it), and it does keep them hot for longer once they come out of the oven, which is why we think restaurants use this method. Wrapping potatoes will also give you a softer, steamed skin, if that's what you like.

Why is aluminum foil bad for you? ›

Small amounts of aluminum can also enter your bloodstream but will leave your body quickly through the urine. Research shows that cooking aluminum at high temperatures and the use of acidic foods, salt and spices did perpetuate a greater amount of leaching of the mineral.

Why we don't use aluminium foil? ›

One of the other reasons why we shouldn't store leftover food in aluminium foil is that it doesn't do a good enough job to keep oxygen from getting into the food. This allows bacteria to grow inside the food, which may spoil the food the next day and it'll go bad just as quickly as if you hadn't wrapped it up at all.

What are the side effects of aluminium foil? ›

While the main health risks for most people are longterm, it is possible to be exposed to dangerous levels of aluminum. Among the symptoms of toxic aluminum exposure: confusion, muscle weakness, aching bones, seizures and slow growth (in children).

Why should you wrap foil around a doorknob at night? ›

If you have ever had a problem with the thermal insulation of your main door, then aluminum foil can be very helpful. This material is an excellent heat conductor, which means after wrapping your knob, it will keep your house cooler in summer and warmer in winter.

Which side of aluminum foil should be up? ›

Foil has a shiny side and a dull side because of how it is manufactured. Unless you are using foil that's labeled non-stick, which does have a non-stick side, it does not matter what side you use. Both the shiny and dull sides can be used the same way to cook, freeze, and store food.

Why put foil balls in a toilet tank? ›

While some advocate for aluminum foil balls, asserting they can deionize tank water to prevent clogs and maintain cleanliness, there's limited scientific backing for this claim. Fortunately, there are numerous proven and safe alternatives for toilet maintenance.

What food should not be cooked in aluminum? ›

When it comes to acidic foods like vinegar, lime, or tomatoes, they are responsible for the increasing dissolution of aluminium ions in the food, which is a massive factor in causing health issues. Alzheimer's disease: Recent studies have shown that cooking in aluminium increases the possibility of Alzheimer's disease.

Are baked potatoes unhealthy? ›

In addition to carbohydrates — a needed energy source for your body and brain — potatoes contain a wealth of micronutrients. They're a good source of vitamins, minerals and fiber. As a bonus, potatoes are low in calories, contain no fat or cholesterol, and are sodium-free.

How long will a baked potato stay hot in foil? ›

Usually the local health department determines how long you can hold them, which is typically no more than two hours, but I recommend no more than 45 minutes to keep the integrity of the potato, as the base will turn dark brown and outer skin will wrinkle.

What temperature should a baked potato be cooked at? ›

Potato baking temperatures range from 350˚ to 450˚F. The sweet spot seems to be at 400˚F, a temperature that cooks the potato all the way through and crisps the skin without singeing it.

Why does a hot potato stay hot when wrapped in aluminum foil? ›

Answer and Explanation:

Aluminium is a good reflector of infrared radiation. Thus, wrapping a hot potato in an aluminium foil does not allow the infrared photons to escape. Instead, they are reflected back. This reduces the rate of cooling.

Why should the potatoes not touch on the baking sheet? ›

Potatoes need to cook all the way through, and the best way for that to happen is to make sure the hot air can get to the potato from all sides. If a potato bakes with one side touching a sheet pan, you'll get a hard spot and possibly uneven cooking.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Mr. See Jast

Last Updated:

Views: 5749

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (75 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Mr. See Jast

Birthday: 1999-07-30

Address: 8409 Megan Mountain, New Mathew, MT 44997-8193

Phone: +5023589614038

Job: Chief Executive

Hobby: Leather crafting, Flag Football, Candle making, Flying, Poi, Gunsmithing, Swimming

Introduction: My name is Mr. See Jast, I am a open, jolly, gorgeous, courageous, inexpensive, friendly, homely person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.